One should not violate the laws of Shabbat in order to vote. In both the USA and in Australia (where your email appears to originate) when elections are held on a day that a person cannot vote, including for religious reasons, alternate arrangements are available. The Australian government website voting FAQ notes,
Early voting is available for electors who are unable to vote on election day. This includes electors who for religious reasons are unable to vote on Saturday 14 September 2013. The dates for early voting are to be confirmed but commence soon after the declaration of nominations for candidates standing in the election during the election period.
Postal and pre-poll voting: Electors who for various reasons cannot attend a polling place anywhere in the State or Territory for which they are enrolled on polling day can apply for a 'postal vote'. The AEC will then send them their ballot papers which must be posted back before polling day. Alternatively a 'pre-poll vote' can be cast in person at a pre-poll voting centre or divisional office in the lead up to polling day as soon as early voting becomes available. Early voting dates will be publicised.
In the US, as well, all 50 states and the District of Columbia allow either early voting, unconditional early voting, or absentee voting by mail.
If you feel bound by halakhah (traditional Jewish law), then your answer, as my Orthodox and Conservative colleagues have stated, is clearly “no.”
But if your Jewish identity is not defined by or bound to observance of halakhah, traditional Jewish law, then it might well be “yes.” From a non-halakhic Jewish perspective, your answer might again depend on how you understand concepts like “work,” “rest,” and “holy.” It might further depend on how you experience God, and ultimately on how you choose to respond to the Jewish imperative to observe and remember Shabbat.
Shabbat is traditionally a day when all work is forbidden. It is a day of rest, a day to connect with God, Torah, Israel; a day to reset our spiritual compass to our truest and highest values. Most importantly, Shabbat is defined as kadosh, holy, something special, precious, set apart. Traditionally we observe Shabbat on the seventh day of the week because God observed Shabbat on the seventh day of creation, and we, created in God’s image, yearn to be like God. In Tanakh, the Hebrew bible, God defined Shabbat as holy, and so should we. God ceased from the work of creation, of world-building, and so should we.
So, what is voting to you, and in particular what is this specific vote, the one that coincides with Shabbat, to you?
Is it work, a secular act, part of the mundane world, a brick in the building that defines your every day existence and that separates you from holiness? Does voting separate you from the priorities that transcend quotidian tasks? Notwithstanding these very tasks keep us in the living, breathing state of being that allows us to bring those priorities to bear on this world God created, Shabbat is not for this.
Or is voting a sacred privilege, a sanctifying act, one that protects against the tyranny of material power, brings you face-to-face with your values and ideals? Does voting embody some of those ideals and help you to transcend, for a moment, the ordinary strivings of your daily, secular existence, plugging you into the vision of a just and peaceful world, a world where we may more regularly enjoy the respite and wholeness that Shabbat is meant to bring?
You might also (or instead) give this question the gut-test. Does voting on Shabbat enhance or impede your experience of Shabbat rest and holiness?
And yes, I am aware that I have answered a question with a question. What did you expect?
Copyright 2020 all rights reserved. Jewish Values Online
N O T I C E
THE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN ANSWERS PROVIDED HEREIN ARE THOSE OF THE INDIVIDUAL JVO PANEL MEMBERS, AND DO NOT
NECESSARILY REFLECT OR REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF THE ORTHODOX, CONSERVATIVE OR REFORM MOVEMENTS, RESPECTIVELY.