One kind of story focuses on just the facts and details. These are the kind of stories that you learn in school, particularly in science or a social studies class. Stories like this which tell you where the capital of France is, or who invented the light bulb, or what caused the Civil War.
Then there is another kind of story— which doesn’t bother to tell you all the details, because it is focused instead on teaching you something much deeper and more important about life. These are tales that you have heard from your parents and grandparents, legends and fables that you have read in books, and images that you have seen in (good) movies and television shows.
The stories in the Bible are the second kind of stories. They don’t explain exactly how Moses split the Red Sea, or where all the water went after Noah’s Flood, or even who married Adam and Eve’s sons and kept the world going. They are just not interested in telling you those kind of details. Instead, the stories in the Bible are very focused on teaching us about how to live a good and holy life.
The story of Adam and Eve doesn’t tell us much about how life on Earth actually began (for that, we should look at a science book), but it tells us a lot about what we are doing here: It teaches us that we are all God's children and are made b’tzelem Elohim, which means that we carry a little spark of God inside of us. It teaches us that we are not supposed to damage or destroy this world that we have been given through pollution or violence, but instead should take care of it and keep it safe. It teaches us that if we look back far enough, we are all members of one big family and must treat each other with respect and care.
The Bible isn’t a science book, or a history book—it’s a meaning book. When you read its stories, don’t get stuck on filling in all the little details, but do dig deep into the big messages. They will change your life and help you be part of healing the world.
This is a great question, and there is a great deal of midrash (commentary by our sages about the matter). For my response, let me suggest that the stories in Torah do not need to be understood as historically accurate in order for us to take them seriously, meaningfully. Great stories may not always be factual in order to contain and convey great, profound truths.
Our tradition never thinks taking the text only literally – at face value – is sufficient to understand the meaning(s) found in these sacred tales. Just two examples that are connected to the question: at the beginning of the Torah, why, the sages inquire, was only one human being created? To teach us that no person may say my origins are greater than another’s. Or, similarly, why was one person created? To teach you that whoever destroys one life destroys an entire world; whoever saves one life saves the entire world.
Simply stated, life lessons (ones we still need to embrace and do) more than historical facts are the living heart of our Torah.
Thanks again for the question and for the chance to respond.
Copyright 2020 all rights reserved. Jewish Values Online
N O T I C E
THE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN ANSWERS PROVIDED HEREIN ARE THOSE OF THE INDIVIDUAL JVO PANEL MEMBERS, AND DO NOT
NECESSARILY REFLECT OR REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF THE ORTHODOX, CONSERVATIVE OR REFORM MOVEMENTS, RESPECTIVELY.